21 Best Cigar Subscription Boxes Reviewed
By Jack Cullum
How often do you sit back with a nice cigar? The answer is probably not often enough!
Cigars are the ideal product for the subscription box format. They're hard to find in regular stores, and they reward you for trying new brands and flavors. Every cigar is a new life experience.
Cigar of the month clubs are a great way to treat yourself. Most boxes include an informational newsletter; you'll quickly find yourself as knowledgable as even the most discerning aficionado. Read the pairing advice, and set yourself up with a nice beverage before you smoke.
Some of these subscription boxes are intended for the occasional smoker; others are intended to have you discovering limited edition or rare stogies from around the world.
I'm actually surprised at the level of quality and just flat out enjoyment that some of these boxes provide. Choose a subscription that enhances your current lifestyle and encourages you to get outside of your box.
jack's top picks
Product | Details | Our Rating |
|---|---|---|
 | ||
 | ||
 |
The List of the Best Cigar Subscription Boxes & Cigar of the Month Clubs:
Read on to find reviews on premium hand-rolled, rare limited-edition cigars, free humidors, coupons, free bonus luxury items like cutters, lighters, and cigar cases. These cigar subscription boxes make great gifts!
1. Mike's Cigars
Probably the best all around cigar box, and one of our Editor's Top Picks, Mike's Cigar is the "Super Mario" of cigar subscriptions. Combine that with great prices, everyday blowout sales and it's a no brainer.
Mike's Cigars offers a personal subscription experience. You can choose 5 cigars cigars from their extensive sampler selection to receive each month. Alternatively, you can let Mike's staff of experts to curate your box with cigars based on what they know about your palette. Very bespoke!
This company develops a personal relationship with each of their clients. You'll appreciate the extra thought that goes into each cigar box.
Every package includes five cigars and luxury items like: cutter, lighter, cigar case, etc. You also get a few extra nice items that depend on your membership. Mike's offers Bronze, Silver and Gold levels. You might want to step your game up because they will give you a free deluxe humidor for the two higher tiers.
PROS
CONS
2. The Rare Cigar Club
If you're looking for a truly exceptional cigar experience, look no further than The Rare Cigar Club. This panel of cigar enthusiasts has personally selected some of the finest small batch cigars in the entire world.
They review 12,000 cigars every year, and less than 5% make the final cut. Your monthly subscription includes four high-quality cigars from boutique manufacturers.
Check the box for a society newsletter full of sourcing information, smoking tips, and drink pairings.
Use One of These Codes During Checkout in Your Cart:
$10 off any 4-shipment order: SAVE10
$15 off any prepaid 6-shipment order: SAVE15
$30 off any prepaid 12-shipment order: SAVE30
PROS
CONS
3. Gotham Cigars
Gotham Cigars has been in the online cigar business since 2001. If you want to smoke recognizable brands in a pleasant variety, this is the subscription box for you.
Each monthly subscription box is hand-chosen by Gotham staff. You'll get an interesting mix of popular favorites and limited-edition runs.
Everything you need to smoke is included in the box; use the cigar cutter, light a match, and read the monthly newsletter.
PROS
CONS
Featured Reading
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Why Are Cuban Cigars Illegal in the U.S.?
RELATED: Gift Ideas for Father's Day or Older Men
HOT TOPIC: Stuck Inside? Get Meals Delivered To Your Home!
4. The Original Premium Cigar Club
The same experts who bring you The Rare Cigar Club also offer The Original Premium Cigar Club. Get five different cigars at a great value; each cigar is hand-picked for flavor, quality, and "smokability".
This cigar club offers a decent amount of variety. You'll find different types of tobacco and various cigar shapes from boutique manufacturers around the world.
Customize your membership by frequency; if you're on a budget, the quarterly option is the best choice.
PROS
CONS
5. Great Clubs of America's Cigar of the Month Club
The Clubs of America's Cigar of the Month Club has been in business since 1994. This is a traditional cigar subscription as you know it; get five cigars every month, no questions asked.
Clubs of America's cigar tasting panel travels the world to find rare and premium cigars. You'll get to enjoy a unique variety of blends and styles. Every month's cigars are different, and you won't taste the same cigar twice.
PROS
CONS
6. JR Cigar
When you are sick of smoking the same stogie and want to taste new flavors, just pay a single recurring charge to get five handmade premium cigars from a mixed variety.
Re-ordering from JR Cigar is simple and efficient. If you decide that a single cigar is right for you, you can switch your recurring shipment to just that brand.
Let us upgrade ya'. JR Plus members get a free bonus cigar! On top of that you get a free gift when pre paying 6 months. Kick back a relax because you are sure to get a cigar that you like every month. JR is a good choice for the "set it and forget it" type of cigar enthusiast.
PROS
CONS
Featured Reading
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Will You Survive What's Coming? Check Out The Best Survival Subscriptions!
RELATED: Have A Nice Glass Of Wine With That Cigar: Best Wine Subscriptions.
Southern Cigar Co. has a no-nonsense cigar package. Order a box of cigars; they'll choose four amazing stogies and ship them to you on a monthly basis.
Everyone gets the same cigars each month, and cigars are shipped in a single batch.This sweet and simple cigar subscription is a good choice if you're just looking for some quality cigars.
Explore new flavors without worrying about the details; Southern Cigar Co. always makes excellent choices.
PROS
CONS
8. Stogiebird
Stogiebird does cigar subscriptions and nothing but. This unique subscription service has all of the convenience and none of the hassle.
Stogiebird works with small cigar manufacturers to deliver handcrafted products. You can check their blog for a list of the brands that you might see in each month's box.
PROS
CONS
Treat yourself to a monthly indulgence with the Luxury Cigar Club. You'll get either three or five high-quality cigars every month for a price tag that's not as high as you might think.
The cigars are hand picked, and the company owners work hard to provide good value to their customers. The Luxury Cigar Club has three membership tiers. Platinum membership is the best value; it comes with five cigars and the occasional gift or perk.
The Diamond membership is significantly more expensive, but it includes rare and aged cigars; contact the company to get on their waiting list.
PROS
CONS
Thompson Cigar has been delivering mail-order cigars since 1915. You can count Thompson Cigar to deliver great smokes, decent prices, and fresh cigars every time.
Your Sampler of the Month will include five different cigars and a Cigar Tour newsletter. Every sampler is different; you might get Thompson private label cigars, new brands, or even limited-edition smokes.
If you fall in love with a specific cigar, order more on the Thompson Cigar website.
PROS
CONS
11. Corona Cigar Company
Corona Cigar Company brings you six cigars every month. This discount cigar retailer is able to provide an exceptional mix of brands, blends, and cigar styles in every box.
Corona works with internationally renowned brands to find some of the best smokes around. Re-ordering your favorites is easy, and you can use your membership discount to get an excellent price.
PROS
CONS
12. Privada Cigar Club
If you're looking for rare and luxury cigars, check out the Privada Cigar Club. Each box contains three high-quality cigars of different rarities.
Privada specializes in cigars that you can't buy anymore. You'll taste limited edition runs, aged cigars from years ago, and rare finds that aren't on store shelves.
This is a great subscription package for the cigar enthusiast who's tired of the usual fare.
What is the cost of Privada Cigar Club? Read our FULL REVIEW here!
PROS
CONS
13. Cigar Federation
Cigar Federation keeps a fresh inventory full of famous brands and factory direct boutiques. Their monthly selection is used to create a unique cigar subscription package with very high-quality smokes.
This is the cigar subscription to choose if you smoke cigars on a consistent basis. Delivery dates are fairly customizable, and you're guaranteed to get fresh cigars.
PROS
CONS
14. CigarClub.com
CigarClub.com uses a detailed discovery process to match cigars with customers. You'll be asked questions about your favorite foods and the drinks you enjoy every night.
When you're done, CigarClub.com will send you a curated monthly box that suits your tastes.
Leave feedback to make the selection process even more accurate.
Know more about CigarClub.com by reading our FULL REVIEW here!
PROS
CONS
15. Cigar by Vices
Robb Vices does luxury subscription boxes. Cigar by Vices is a luxury cigar subscription that's only delivered four times a year.
Inside the box, you'll find amazing cigars, unique accessories, and permission to indulge.
These expensive smokes are worth the price, and you won't find them elsewhere.
PROS
CONS
16. CIGR
When you want a small pile of cigars for an excellent price, order the CIGR subscription box.
You'll get eight cigars every month, and the price is only slightly higher than most subscriptions on this list. Your cigars show up in a lovingly-branded humidified tube.
The contents include a mix of boutique products, well-known brands, and exciting finds. Each package contains a satisfying number of pleasant smoking experiences.
PROS
CONS
17. Good Cigar Co.
If you feel like cigar samplers never appeal to you, you should try Good Cigar's unique algorithm. You'll need to take a quiz that asks about your smoking experience and flavor preferences.
The intelligent concierge will then choose a few cigars that are perfect for your tastes. Good Cigar Co. claims that their algorithm is always getting smarter.
It's a unique approach to subscription boxes that seems to work well for their customer base.
PROS
CONS
18. Ezra Cigar and Coffee of the Month Club
Smoky flavors just go together. Ezra Cigar and Coffee of the Month Club provides a perfectly bitter experience with two exceptional products.
A fresh small batch of Ezra's roasted coffee is shipped in each box. Enjoy your java with five cigars from Ezra lines, one of which is the new monthly release.
These flavors are all made by the same company, so they're guaranteed to pair well together.
PROS
CONS
19. Cigar.com
The Cigar.com subscription box is built around a simple formula. Each box includes one featured cigar, two recommended cigars, and two everyday smokes. Introduce yourself to new flavors and look for your next favorite cigar.
Every Cigar.com package follows a slight theme. You might get cigars from the same country, in the same flavor palette, or wrapped in a similar fashion.
This extra touch makes all five cigars feel like a single monthly experience.
PROS
CONS
20. Amazing Clubs Cigar of the Month Club
Amazing Clubs does monthly subscriptions for a variety of fine goods. Their Cigar of the Month Club features five premium cigars from specialty growers.
These brands and batches are hard to find; you'll get aged rarities and limited editions.
You'll also get the Tobacco Road newsletter with details about your purchases.
PROS
CONS
21. Small Batch Cigar
Small Batch Cigar is a good way to get access to boutique cigars without paying too much. Their lowest tier option gives you two to three cigars for less than any other subscription on this list.
If you want more cigars, you can purchase the larger subscriptions. Small Batch Cigar lets you re-order every cigar in your box.
The cigars are in limited edition runs, so you might need to make your purchase before that flavor sells out.
PROS
CONS
What is the best cigar subscription box?
Each of these cigar subscription packages is suited for a different type of smoker. Cigar Federation is great for the consistent smoker. The Luxury Cigar Club caters to fine cigar buyers, and Privada boast a great community that caters to rarity enthusiasts.
Good Cigar Co. offers an algorithmically customized experience. Stogiebird is the microbrewery of cigar subscriptions.
It's hard to choose just one of these subscription options; they're all great deals by truly enthusiastic companies, and you couldn't go wrong with any of the cigars on this list.
With that in mind, my choice for best cigar subscription box would go to The Rare Cigar Club.
These guys just knock it out the park every time. You can tell they have professionals selecting each premium stick. You feel lucky to have even tried these offerings after every smoke.
If you're looking for a good all-around experience, this is the box for you.
Head over to The Rare Cigar Club today to see what they're offering this month.
- Jack
If you enjoyed this post please consider sharing on social media. You can pin this image to your Cigar or Whiskey Lovers board.
Discover More Boxes...
About the Author:
Jack Cullum aka "The Box Man" is known to bust a box or two open! He is super into it really! He is also the lead writer for Subscription Boxes for Men. So please connect with him on social and may all your boxes be great!
