10 Best Fly Fishing Subscription Boxes Reviewed

UPDATE: I narrowed down our list to only the 10 very best boxes. Enjoy!

Fishing is a beloved pastime that has been passed down from one generation to the next for many, many years. I remember fondly the days I would go fishing with my father. In the end, you are bound to know someone who loves to fish.

Below I have curated some of the very best subscriptions that will deliver all the gear and supplies you need for a fun day out on the lake.

Many providers below offer a 1-time box, that makes a great gift for any fishing lover. Catch 1 today!

Jack's Top Picks

Product

Details

My Rating

Lucky tackle box subscription
  • Excellent value for the price
  • Customer service
  • Free shipping in the United States
Mystery Tackle Box Subscription
  • 4 great monthly crate variations
  • Regular and Pro options include a ton of fish species options
  • Monthly, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month plans
Freestone Fly Fishing Company Subscription Box
  • Great price for overall value
  • Excellent customer reviews
  • Bonus 1-year membership to Trout Unlimited

List of The Best Fly Fishing Subscription Boxes:

Here is a great list discounts and coupon codes to help you with your precision fly fishing. Makes a great gift for any fishing lover!

LTB features three great sizes of one of the premier fishing subscriptions, including Regular, XL, and Tournament. You can subscribe to either size a pick a species: Bass, Panfish, Trout, or Catfish to best fit your needs and fishing goals.

There are also multi-species options available. The Regular plan arrives each month with 5 great new baits at a $25 value. For more baits and to discover even more new products, choose the XL or Tournament versions.

Click here get $5 OFF your first box NOW!

Feelin' lucky? Read our FULL REVIEW of LTB here!

Lucky tackle box subscription

PROS

  • Free shipping in the United States
  • Cancel easily at any time
  • 3 great versions to fit your fishing needs

CONS

  • Only available in certain species at certain times
  • Not available in one month, three month, or more plans

The Mystery Tackle Box is a subscription service that provides a lot of amazing variation for peoples different needs. Choose between a Regular or a Pro box in a wide variety of species, including Bass, Trout, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish, Catfish, and Walleye.

In addition, a special Elite box is available in Bass and Multi-species for serious fishermen and women.

Solve the mystery of reeling in the big one by reading our FULL REVIEW of Mystery Tackle Box here!

Mystery Tackle Box Subscription

PROS

  • 4 great plan choices, including a Beginner's Plan
  • Regular and Pro options include Bass, Trout, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish, Catfish, and Walleye species options
  • Available in different plans, including monthly, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month plans

CONS

  • Only two species options - Bass and Multi-species - available in the Elite plan
  • Past shipments unavailable for purchase

Enjoying glowing reviews of dozens of happy customers -- Freestone offers a lot of perks along with their goodies. Each month, you will receive a collection of flies that are picked out of some of the best brands and varieties.

Freestone offers a Freshwater Trout fly fishing option or a Fly-Tying option to bring you the latest materials for the best ties. As a bonus, you get step-by-step guides to your new gear, as well as tips and tricks.

PROS

  • Great price for overall value
  • Ships regularly every 4th of the month
  • Bonus 1-year membership to Trout Unlimited

CONS

  • Past shipments not available for purchase
  • Only 2 versions to choose from

Isle brings the goods for the ultimate outdoorsman to your door. You can opt to receive a Seasonal, which can come for only 1, 2, or 4 quarters. The Isle also features two one-time only versions, the Starter and the National Parks versions.

The Starter gives you everything you need to begin backpacking like a pro, including a sleeping pad, head lamp, and water filter. The National Parks option is the perfect kit for exploring the amazing parks in the United States.

Oh, and the Seasonal Boxes provide themed camping and outdoors products.

Isle Box Subscription

PROS

  • Free shipping on all plans
  • Friendly for men or women
  • Available in three versions

CONS

  • Includes products for general outdoors activities
  • One of the more expensive options

How much does iFiles cost? Plans start as low as £7.00 , or $8.74, per month.

Sometimes you like a no nonsense approach and iFlies brings great new flies and lures to your door every month -- that's it. And they do it all the way from the UK.

Choose from 5 Trout Flies, 10 Trout Flies, 5 Salmon Flies, 5 Warm Water Flies, or 20 Trout Flies - a special Double Up offer.

This is great gift for anyone who spends a lot of time fishing during the spring and summer months and wants to grow their fly collection.

iFlies Subscription Box

PROS

  • Variation in products offered with 6 different plans
  • Choose between trout, salmon, or saltwater species options
  • Arrives in fun tin packaging every month

CONS

  • Ships intentionally from UK, check site to see if they ship to you
  • No multi-month plans available

The Fly Crate helps you hook the biggest trout and bass with uniquely curated items every month. Each crate is accompanied by a great how-to magazine that will help you get started with your new goodies.

Choose between three plans - the Explorer, the Troutbum, and the Lifestyle - so that you get the fishing supplies you need to suit your level of commitment. 

The Fly Crate is great to give as a gift or keep for yourself, and every purchase gives money to programs that help American veterans. Conscious Capitalism at it's best. #WinWin

THE FLY CRATE SUBSCRIPTION BOX

PROS

  • Plans offered in 3 levels of value
  • Help veterans with every purchase
  • Includes how-to magazine with every shipment

CONS

  • Only available in Bass and Trout at this time
  • Similar to others that have more selection

Warriors offers one of the widest selection of fish species to chose from with any plan. Pick your favorite species that you fish, including Bass, Redfish, Walleye, Crappie, Catfish, and Trout.

Each purchase also supports veterans through donations to organizations dedicated to their needs.

Find out more about Warriors Tackle Box by visiting our FULL REVIEW here!

Warriors Tackle Box Subscription

PROS

  • Available in 3 versions depending on needs
  • Wide selection of fish species, including Bass, Redfish, Walleye, Crappie, Catfish, and Trout
  • Can choose monthly, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month plans

CONS

  • Past deliveries unavailable for purchase
  • Not as pleasing style or packaging

RTB offers a huge selection of great options, including Big Bass, Big Bass Mini, Big Catfish , Big Crappie, Big Fly Fishing, Big Striper, Big Walleye, Big Saltwater, Big Shark, Big Fly Fishing, and Big Ice Fishing.

You can choose from 1, 3 (quarterly), 6, and 12-month plans, depending on how often you plan on fishing or need new gear.

With so many options and flexibility, it's hard not to find something to love here.

Fishin' for more info about RTB? Check out our FULL REVIEW here!


Reel Tackle Box Subscription

PROS

  • A wide variation of options available to fit your needs
  • A monthly with more products and less gimmicks
  • Multiple species options available, including Bass, Striper, Walleye, Crappie, and Catfish

CONS

  • Only the Big Bass is available in a smaller, less expensive option
  • Past shipments unavailable for purchase

Post Fly ships awesome curated flies, gear, and stoke monthly to your door. Each delivery is created to complement the season, and you can choose different types depending on your species preference and location.

Choose from Trout, Saltwater, Warmwater, Steelhead & Salmon, or Fly Tying. Post Fly offers two versions: Regular and Guide Series. In the Regular version, you will find over $25 of high-quality flies every month.

The Guide Series offers over double that value of flies, as well as many other great fishing accessories every month.

Try Post fly subscription box today!

PROS

  • Choose species/location preference
  • Available in 2 great versions
  • Free shipping in the United States

CONS

  • No option to subscribe for every 3 months, 6 months, etc
  • Previous boxes not available for purchase

A double dragon - this is one of the best crates for hunting AND fishing fanatics. Each shipment arrives every 15th of the month, depending on your plan.

One of the awesome benefits of Sportsman's is the Gear Guide who helps curate the gear in your crate. You walk away very informed, so you can enjoy the outdoors that much more.

Check out our FULL REVIEW of The Sportsman's Box here.

The Sportsman’s Box Subscription

PROS

  • 3 great options depending on needs
  • Available to ship monthly or every 3 months
  • Includes a gear guide with every delivery

CONS

  • Includes fishing AND hunting products
  • Past deliveries unavailable for purchase

What is the best fishing subscription box?

Each of these amazing fishing subscription boxes provides you the tools you need to have a great day out on the lake or sitting beside the river. These boxes also make the best gifts for a dedicated fisherman or woman who is always eager to try new products.

The best fishing subscription box for my money is the Reel Tackle Box. This monthly treasure trove offers the best value for your money, with some of the best curated products. You can choose from a huge selection of boxes to fit your favorite species, location, and type of fishing, as well.

Check out each of these boxes at the links provided for more information. Fishing fans will no be disappointed by the wide selection of products offered by these great brands. You can truly find an option that will excite you and benefit your fishing game "at the same damn time"!

- Jack


Let's get social, share this! ;)

Discover More Boxes...

Jack Cullum

Jack Cullum aka "The Box Man" is known to bust a box or two open! He is super into it really! He is also the lead writer for Subscription Boxes for Men. So please connect with him on social and may all your boxes be great!